Planning & Land 08 min read

How to Read a Site Appraisal

A development appraisal tests whether a proposed scheme is financially viable. Homes England's guidance puts the test simply: a project is viable if the value it generates exceeds the development costs with an allowance for profit, and an appraisal is only ever as robust as its inputs, so it is essential to understand the assumptions whichever tool is used (Homes England, Financial viability for housing-led projects).

 

This guide explains the parts of a typical appraisal, how to read its results, and what official guidance says about the main assumptions.

The parts of an appraisal

Homes England describes development appraisals as a residual method of valuation: development costs are deducted from the anticipated proceeds, and what is left is usually either development profit or land value. The basic residual method is built from four elements (Homes England, Financial viability for housing-led projects):

Element

What it covers

Gross development value (GDV)

Total income from the scheme, including private sales, affordable housing and the investment value of any commercial space, less purchaser's costs

Total development costs

Build costs, abnormal costs, remediation, infrastructure, professional fees, Section 106 and CIL, marketing and finance

Developer profit

Typically a percentage of GDV for residential schemes

Residual land value

GDV minus total development costs, including profit: the amount the developer can afford to pay for the land

The same method can be run the other way: where land has already been bought, GDV minus total costs, including the price paid for land, gives the residual profit.

The assumptions to check

Homes England's checklist of appraisal inputs covers revenue, grant, preliminaries, site preparation, build costs, enhanced design or policy-related costs, on-plot external works, strategic infrastructure, abnormal costs, contingency, CIL, Section 106 and Section 278 costs, sales and marketing costs, build and sales rates, finance costs and developer profit. On finance, it notes that it is usual to assume all development funding is borrowed, with interest charged on outstanding debt during development (Homes England, Financial viability for housing-led projects).

Housing association appraisals

Housing associations usually test rented homes differently. The NHF guide to development appraisal describes the net present value (NPV) of future net rent compared with the finance required, alongside measures such as internal rate of return (IRR) and payback. Residual land value for rented homes is found by adjusting the land price until the NPV reaches zero (National Housing Federation, Understanding Development Appraisal, 2015).

Reading the results

Residual land value against benchmark land value

In planning viability, the residual land value is compared with a benchmark land value (BLV). Homes England's guidance says a BLV should (Homes England, Financial viability for housing-led projects):

 

  • be based on existing use value (EUV);
  • allow for a premium to the landowner;
  • reflect abnormal costs, site-specific infrastructure costs and professional site fees;
  • be informed by market evidence, including current uses, costs and values;
  • be based on policy-compliant developments, including affordable housing, where recent market value evidence is used, with any adjustment for policy costs identified and evidenced where it is not.

The premium should give a reasonable incentive for a landowner to bring land forward while fully allowing for the cost of meeting policy requirements. Alternative use value may also inform the benchmark (Homes England, Financial viability for housing-led projects). Under the NPPF (August 2026), neither the price paid for land nor a price agreed through an option justifies failing to meet plan policies (NPPF, policy DM5).

Developer return

Planning practice guidance on viability has stated that, for plan-making, a return of 15% to 20% of GDV may be considered suitable, with a lower figure potentially more appropriate for affordable housing, and viability reviews often refer to that range (Shoosmiths; New Forest National Park Authority). The government updated the viability guidance in December 2025 (MHCLG, Chief Planner Newsletter, December 2025).

 

Its consultation on the draft NPPF, which ran from 16 December 2025 to 10 March 2026, proposed standardised viability inputs in a new annex, including 17.5% of GDV for market-led development and views on 6% of GDV for affordable housing (Charles Russell Speechlys, February 2026). That annex was not carried into the NPPF published in August 2026. Viability assessments continue to follow the viability planning practice guidance, which remains the source of standardised inputs (Irwin Mitchell; Philip Barnes, Savills, August 2026). The government's consultation response refers to MHCLG reviewing that guidance as soon as possible (Philip Barnes, Savills, August 2026), so the figures may change.

NPV and IRR

In a housing association appraisal, an NPV surplus means the present value of net rent exceeds the finance required, and a deficit means the scheme needs further subsidy or income from elsewhere. The IRR is the discount rate at which the NPV surplus is zero, and is commonly used to show how much buffer a scheme has against uncertain projections (NHF, 2015).

Checking the assumptions

Build costs

Build cost data from the Building Cost Information Service (BCIS) is widely used in viability assessment (Lichfields, Fine Margins). A council viability training presentation notes that use of BCIS is commonplace but has its limitations, and gives an example of an applicant submitting build costs below the BCIS lower quartile (Mansfield District Council).

Contingency and externals

The first edition of Lichfields' Fine Margins research, published in August 2021, found externals typically assumed at 10% to 20% of build costs and contingency at 2.5% to 5% of build costs in viability assessments, with site typology and risk profile dictating the approach (Fine Margins, first edition). A second edition, reviewing 144 local plan and CIL viability studies, was published on 13 May 2026 (Fine Margins: Second Edition).

Rent assumptions

For affordable rented homes, long-term rent assumptions should be consistent with government rent policy. From April 2026, Social Rent and Affordable Rent increases are limited to CPI plus 1 percentage point a year for at least 10 years, with additional convergence for Social Rent homes below formula rent from April 2027 (MHCLG, Policy statement on rents for social housing).

Sensitivity

Homes England notes that off-the-shelf appraisal tools usually include the ability to run sensitivity analyses on key variables. Its guidance also links to its own Development Appraisal Tool (Homes England, Financial viability for housing-led projects), but that tool was withdrawn on 20 April 2026 (GOV.UK).

 

Proval Vantage, SDS's development appraisal software, reports NPV, IRR and payback with sensitivity analysis and appraises multiple tenures in a single appraisal (G-Cloud 14 listing). It lets users stress-test grant, build cost and sales price and see where the viability threshold sits (SDS).